TEMPO and HUP

A Blog for Civil Debate on Political Philosophy

A Blog for Civil Debate on Political Philosophy

Two Rescues: A Tale for TEMPO

July 13, 2018 by Alan Bernstein 1 Comment

“Help!” called the old man thrashing desperately in the river’s current. A passing woodsman rushed in and, with great difficulty, pulled him ashore. Stumbling downstream, they reached a fenced-in cabin near the water’s edge. They sought refuge from the owner who sheltered them awhile but then forced them to work on the surrounding wall.

The woodsman objected, “I rescued this old man freely, why won’t you do the same and release us?”

Their captor explained, “My father and I fished here for years. Eventually we improved our catch by stringing a net across the water. Because of the net we dominated the village downstream and enclosed the cabin to protect ourselves. Since he died, I force others to maintain the wall, and so must you, because you owe me your lives. Never ask anything of another, as you two have done, because that puts you in their debt. Set an example of independence and everyone will be free.”

The old man objected, “You should support your neighbors, not hold them down. Your net harms them. They are surely weak and resentful. Should the need arise, they would be unable to help you—and unwilling.”

“Help me? That’s ridiculous. Those people are lazy or they would have moved upstream.”

The old man answered: “I understand why you urge everyone to be independent. We should each be an example to others. But what you have described is interdependence. You and your father built the net together. You need your captives to keep up this compound. You have received help, so you should give it. The more people help others; the more people help others.”

That night, a storm arose. Wind shattered the roof. A falling beam landed on the fisherman’s chest and pinned him on his back. He was in pain and could hardly breathe. The old man and the woodsman tried but could not lift the plank. The woodsman ran downstream and returned with four neighbors who removed the beam and sheltered the fisherman in a corner of the palisade. Then the six threw the beam into the river to puncture the net. The old man tended his former captor, and the woodsman helped him repair the cabin. After a time, the villagers and the fisherman shared the river equally.

Filed Under: TEMPO and HUP Tagged With: harm, help, interdependence, neighbors, rescue, share

Comments

  1. Ed Loechler says

    December 10, 2021 at 2:17 pm

    Nice allegory. Sigh. They’ll never understand.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • HOME
  • ABOUT
  • ON ADDING COMMENTS

MY POSTS

  • Guns, again.
  • Elon Musk, Putin, and MDM
  • January 6 Sedition Leader Exposed
  • EQUAL OPPORTUNITY: Goal and Slogan
  • Inertia Hobbles New England’s Energy Transition
  • Texas School Bill Hinders Education
  • A Loss For Democrats? I Think Not!
  • Thought Control in the U.S. Today
  • The Religious Right Invents Religious Rights
  • Collusion Collision
  • No Surprise
  • The Barr-Trump Monarchy
  • Not Too Nice
  • Shortchanged !
  • Substantive Wrongs
  • Static Action
  • Race: How We Got Here
  • Sanctuary for Immigrants
  • Conscience and Citizenship
  • Tackling Socialism
  • The Amygdala Between Kindness and Cruelty
  • Charity and Taxes
  • Hurt People
  • Altruistic Living Kidney Donation
  • Altruism in Cells
VALUABLE LINKS

Reflecting Broad Spectrum

  • Real Clear Politics + top polling data
  • All Sides: unbiased, balanced news
  • Intelligence Squared
  • PLOS ONE

Leaning Right

  • Learn Liberty
  • National Review
  • Business Insider
  • AynRand.org

Leaning Left

  • AlterNet
  • Talking Points Memo
  • ThinkProgress
  • Truthout

Compassion and Altruism

  • Stanford CCARE
  • Effective Altruism

Environment

  • Grist
  • Plenty

Recent Comments

  • Anne on The Amygdala Between Kindness and Cruelty
  • Alan Bernstein on Texas School Bill Hinders Education
  • Jonathan Beck on Texas School Bill Hinders Education
  • Alan Bernstein on Texas School Bill Hinders Education
  • Louisa Rose on Texas School Bill Hinders Education

Copyright © 2025 · Beautiful Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in